Choosing Textbooks or Articles
David Kember
Context:
The author describes how to determine whether textbooks
and articles are suitable for a distance education course.
Source:
Kember, David. 1991. "Choosing Textbooks or Articles." In
David Kember, Writing Study Guides. Bristol: Technical
and Educational Services Ltd., pp. 31-35.
Copyright:
pending.
|
Preview
If your course uses a study guide, you rely on a textbook
or a collection of readings to provide the bulk of the content.
If your course is to be effective it is therefore vital
to choose the right books or readings. This unit gives some
guidelines for making the best choice.
The amount of reading is considered first, with a warning
about overloading students. Criteria are then suggested
for assessing books and readings.
Tne unit ends by looking at the copyright implications
of compiling a collection of readings. Advice is given on
procedures to follow to obtain copyright clearance.
Objectives
- By the end of this unit you should:
- have selected a suitable textbook and/or collection
of readings for your study guide.
- be aware of the potential danger of overloading students
- have enough knowledge of copyright requirements to obtain
permission to reproduce extracts in a reader.
Contents of Unit 3
- How Much Reading?
- Selecting Books or Readings
- Writing Style or Readability
- Copyright Permission
How Much Reading?
| &
83-85 |
When assessing your students' workload remember to
take into account the study guide, the activities
and the textbook or readings.
|
| do not overload |
Heed well Rowntree's warning on overloading
students!
|
When compiling a book of readings it is easy
to select too much.
|
All those articles, which seem interesting and useful
to you, can amount to an overwhelming burden of reading
for your students.
In education quality should be more important than
quantity. Much of the information and knowledge contained
in educational courses becomes outdated before too
long. Much is never used by students. In an era of
rapid social and technological change students benefit
more from learning how to become independent learners
than from being stuffed with information.
In the next activity you are asked to select the
textbook or readings for your course. When you do
this make sure that you estimate the time it will
take your students to read all the material!
Selecting Books or Readings
You now come to an important decision. You need to
select the books and/or readings to provide the main
source of content.
|
| &
87-89 |
Rowntree provides a valuable set of guidelines (figure
5.1) for evaluating reading materials. Treat the guidelines
as a measure of how much materials will have to be
adapted if used with a study guide. For example, when
using the criterion "teaching approach", few textbooks
will provide activities or exercises to allow the
student to interact with the materials. However you
can provide these in your study guide. You are unlikely
to find perfect materials so ask yourself whether
the deficiencies can be rectified in your study guide
in an efficient way.
Writing Style or Readability
|
| &
207-232 |
If you wish to assess reading matter in a more detailed
way, then it is worth skimming through Rowntree's
chapter 10, entitled "Making your lesson readable".
The criteria for plain conversational writing can
be used to assess possible books.
|
| Fog index |
You could also try one of the readability tests on
potential books (pp. 230-231). Do not take the results
too literally. Scientific texts can score poorly on
the Fog Index because many of the technical words
are long. However if the terms are used repeatedly
and are well defined when first met, they may not
present reading difficulties.
It is easy to get a low Fog Index. You use short
sentences. You do that all the time. You never use
long words. It does not make for easy reading. In
fact reading is difficult!
Copyright Permission
|
If you wish to compile a set of reading then
I suggest you take action on copyright permission
as soon as possible.
|
Obtaining copyright permission can be a lengthy process
so start early or permission might not come through
before the beginning of the course. If a copyright
owner refuses permission or demands an exorbitant
fee it is better to know early on, so that alternative
readings can be found.
The process of obtaining permission can be particularly
lengthy if you have trouble locating the copyright
owner. Addresses can change and it is not always clear
from a book or journal who owns the copyright. It
can take two or three letters before a satisfactory
reply is received.
|
| &
368-373 |
Rowntree covers
- copyright material
- infringement
- ownership of copyright
- obtaining permission
- protection of copyright.
It is worth strengthening the third point on page
372. Many of the larger publishers automatically ask
for details such as:
|
| details in request letter |
- print run
- intended use
- distribution
- whether reprints will be made.
It can save a letter if you give the information
to start with. You are less likely to be charged a
fee if the copied material is part of a free course
for a small number of underprivileged students in
your home town, than if it is going in an expensive
book with worldwide sales. So if you are in the home
town category make sure you tell the copyright owner.
If you obtain permission to copy any material you
reproduce, then you are safe as long as you stick
to any conditions imposed by the copyright owner.
There are some rights to make copies without having
obtained permission. The chief of is the fair dealing
right to copy insubstantial portions. In addition
there are now provisions for educational institutions
to make copies, for student use, which are, covered
by a standard license fee payment
I have no intention of offering advice on the use
of these provisions. They can make your task much
easier but copyright legislation varies from country
to country and changes to legislation occur in order
to keep pace with advances in technologies, such as
video recorders and computers. Each of the acts are
replete with phrases such as substantial portion
or fair dealing which need careful interpretation
in the light of test cases.
|
| seek advice |
The references cited below will be of some help,
but the best advice is:
Copyright legislation affects every educational institution
so most have assigned someone to oversee the operation
of copyright procedures. Most organisations have well
established procedures in place.
|
If you are in any doubt whatever, request permission
from the copyright owner.
|
|
| & |
Moore, L.G. (1987)
The Australian law of copyright and its application
to distance education.
Distance Education, 8, 1, 18-37.
Unlike most works on copyright this article is easy
to read. If you are involved in distance education
in Australia it is highly recommended.
|
| & |
Lahore, J. (1979)
Intellectual property in Australia
Sydney: Butterworths.
A more comprehensive guide to Australian copyright
legislation.
|
|